Book Review: the Promise and Perils of fMRI – Education & Teacher Conferences Skip to main content

Book Review: the Promise and Perils of fMRI

AdobeStock_98194970_Credit

Russell Poldrack reviews Sex, Lies, and Brain Scans: How fMRI Reveals What Really Goes on in our Minds, by Barbara J. Sahakian and Julia Gottwald.

As Poldrack emphasizes, it’s falling-off-a-log easy to overestimate the power of fMRI: in fields such as lie-detection and neuro-prediction, we regularly see hype and misunderstanding rather than sober and substantial understanding.

My favorite line from the review: “[N]euroimaging is usually only as solid as the behavioural research that underpins it.”

The take-away for teachers: brain images from neuroscience-world are compelling, but we should be sure to have psychology research as well before we make changes in our schools and classrooms.


Recent Blogs

The Shelf-Life of Research: When Education Theories Evolve…
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

To most of us, research conclusions have an air of...

Enjoyment or Skill? The Case of Reading [Repost]
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

Student motivation has always been a concern; never more so...

Book Review: 10 to 25, by David Yeager
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

As long as humans have lived into their teens, adults...