Does Size Matter? – Education & Teacher Conferences Skip to main content

Does Size Matter?

AdobeStock_88957262_Credit

Is a man’s amygdala larger than a woman’s? And: why does it matter?

The amygdala is central to neural networks that process strong negative emotions: especially fear and anger. Because psychological studies have shown gender differences in the expression of these emotions, researchers have hypothesized that men might have a larger amygdala, on average, than women do.

That is, gendered behavior might have a biological foundation in a gendered brain.

According to a recent meta-analysis of 46 studies: not so much. Lise Eliot’s research team found no statistically significant difference between male and female amydalae.

(More precisely: men’s amygdalae are–on average–10% larger than women’s; but, men’s BRAINS are–on average–10% larger than women’s. So–relative to brain size–there is no meaningful difference.)

Of course, male and female brains are not identical. And: behavioral differences between genders are important.

However, if Eliot’s results hold up, we can no longer say that these behavioral differences result from meaningfully different amygdala sizes.


Recent Blogs

Retrieval Practice and Feedback: Do Students Know What They Know?
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

When I talk with teachers about retrieval practice, one question...

Interleaving: Who Benefits Most?
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

For over three decades, cognitive science researchers have championed desirable...

Do Schools Kill Creativity?
Andrew Watson
Andrew Watson

Schools often get a bad rap. One of the most...